My all original (so far) '47 Cub has a magneto & distributor ignition. However the later models only have a distributor.
Was a magneto essentially unneccessary when hand cranks became a thing of the past?
What's the difference between a magneto and a distributor? Since my tractor has both, I presume they're not that closely related. What makes the latest models not need a magneto?
For what it's worth, I'm going to be converting this tractor to 12V and wondering if I want to keep the current magneto/distributor combo or go with a later distributor only setup. BTW, I don't ever plan to hand crank this thing.
This site uses cookies to maintain login information on FarmallCub.Com. Click the X in the banner upper right corner to close this notice. For more information on our privacy policy, visit this link: Privacy Policy
NEW REGISTERED MEMBERS: Be sure to check your SPAM/JUNK folders for the activation email.
Magneto vs. Distributor
Forum rules
Notice: For sale and wanted posts are not allowed in this forum. Please use our free classifieds or one of our site sponsors for your tractor and parts needs.
Notice: For sale and wanted posts are not allowed in this forum. Please use our free classifieds or one of our site sponsors for your tractor and parts needs.
- DieselDennis
- 10+ Years
- Posts: 185
- Joined: Thu Feb 21, 2013 10:04 pm
- Zip Code: 39042
- eBay ID: ccbil
- Tractors Owned: '48 Cub (Great Granddaddy's)
And some bigger ones..... - Location: Brandon, MS
Magneto vs. Distributor
'48 Cub 12V Conversion, Zenith Carb, Electronic Ignition
-
- 10+ Years
- Posts: 4948
- Joined: Tue Jun 08, 2004 3:04 pm
- Zip Code: 14559
- Circle of Safety: Y
- Location: Rochester, NY
Re: Magneto vs. Distributor
Unless you've got something very strange, you have one or the other, not both.
Both magneto and distributors have a distributor cap and wires. Perhaps that is where your confusion is?
The difference is that a magneto generates its own electricity. A distributor uses battery power to make the spark.
The reason they went to a distributor is because it's less maintenance and cheaper to build.
Both magneto and distributors have a distributor cap and wires. Perhaps that is where your confusion is?
The difference is that a magneto generates its own electricity. A distributor uses battery power to make the spark.
The reason they went to a distributor is because it's less maintenance and cheaper to build.
- gitractorman
- 10+ Years
- Posts: 2680
- Joined: Mon Oct 24, 2005 11:35 am
- Zip Code: 14072
- eBay ID: toysforjake
- Tractors Owned: Lots of Cub Cadets!
1951 Farmall Cub
1977 IH Cub
1966 IH Cub
1965 IH Lo Boy
1964 IH Lo Boy
1949 Farmall Cub
Several IH 154 Lo Boys
1979 IH 184 Lo Boy
Simplicity 4416 Sovereign
Simplicity Conquest
Simplicity Legacy 4x4 Diesel
Mitsubishi MT180D 4x4 Diesel - Circle of Safety: Y
- Location: Grand Island, NY
Re: Magneto vs. Distributor
The magneto has a distributor cap, so that it can distribute power to the individual spark plugs It is not the same as a regular distributor. The reason a magneto was used was for the base model tractors that did not have headlights or electric start, is that the magneto generates spark mechanically therefore the tractor could operate without a battery. Also, that was the technology of the day, and as many can attest, they still work today with little problems.
With the addition of electric start and headlights, the magneto still provides spark for the engine, and the generator charges the battery. That's it, and the two sides of the electrical system do not really interact. This tractor will still operate without a battery, however the starter and lights will not function.
When you change to 12v power, you need a coil, starter, generator(or alternator), regulator, etc., and a wiring harness that provides all the wiring to put everything together. The tractor will not operate without a battery or if the battery dies.
Personally, If I had a 1947 tractor that was basically complete, I would fix up the magneto system and keep it original. There's not any real benefit in going to 12v system, other than light bulbs are less expensive and you can jump start it from a car. The down side of going to a 12v system is buying all new components, rewiring everything, fitting in new components, etc. You're probably looking at a couple hundred bucks just for the distributor and alternator alone, not including all the other components you will need. On the other hand, you can probably get a magneto rebuilt for $100, and re-use everything you already have.
If the tractor is tuned properly, it will start, run, operate exactly the same, 6v magneto, or 12v battery. Anyway, just my thoughts.
With the addition of electric start and headlights, the magneto still provides spark for the engine, and the generator charges the battery. That's it, and the two sides of the electrical system do not really interact. This tractor will still operate without a battery, however the starter and lights will not function.
When you change to 12v power, you need a coil, starter, generator(or alternator), regulator, etc., and a wiring harness that provides all the wiring to put everything together. The tractor will not operate without a battery or if the battery dies.
Personally, If I had a 1947 tractor that was basically complete, I would fix up the magneto system and keep it original. There's not any real benefit in going to 12v system, other than light bulbs are less expensive and you can jump start it from a car. The down side of going to a 12v system is buying all new components, rewiring everything, fitting in new components, etc. You're probably looking at a couple hundred bucks just for the distributor and alternator alone, not including all the other components you will need. On the other hand, you can probably get a magneto rebuilt for $100, and re-use everything you already have.
If the tractor is tuned properly, it will start, run, operate exactly the same, 6v magneto, or 12v battery. Anyway, just my thoughts.
Cub Cadets 682, 1811, 1864, Simplicity Legacy XL 4x4 Diesel with FEL, 60" mower, 50" Tiller
-
- 10+ Years
- Posts: 4948
- Joined: Tue Jun 08, 2004 3:04 pm
- Zip Code: 14559
- Circle of Safety: Y
- Location: Rochester, NY
Re: Magneto vs. Distributor
In many ways the magneto is BETTER than a battery ignition. A good magneto will provide a hotter spark than a battery ignition can ever hope to make. A magneto will let the tractor start even though the battery is dead.
Now don't quote me on this but I *think* that battery ignitions give you better advance capability than a mageneto. The battery ignition can advance the timing further as the RPMs increase, giving you better power and better fuel economy.
Now don't quote me on this but I *think* that battery ignitions give you better advance capability than a mageneto. The battery ignition can advance the timing further as the RPMs increase, giving you better power and better fuel economy.
- DieselDennis
- 10+ Years
- Posts: 185
- Joined: Thu Feb 21, 2013 10:04 pm
- Zip Code: 39042
- eBay ID: ccbil
- Tractors Owned: '48 Cub (Great Granddaddy's)
And some bigger ones..... - Location: Brandon, MS
Re: Magneto vs. Distributor
Pardon my ignorance as I was barely around before everything was EFI.
I think I was led astray by the '47 operators manual that discusses the magneto, and then discusses the distributor gear and distributor cap on the next page. So in this sense, the distributor is part of the overall magneto.
I think I was led astray by the '47 operators manual that discusses the magneto, and then discusses the distributor gear and distributor cap on the next page. So in this sense, the distributor is part of the overall magneto.
'48 Cub 12V Conversion, Zenith Carb, Electronic Ignition
- bob in CT
- Team Cub Mentor
- Posts: 6018
- Joined: Thu Jun 07, 2007 9:34 am
- Zip Code: 06040
- Tractors Owned: 77 Cub (red); 74 Cub; 52 Cub; 50 Cub ( post-demo)
- Circle of Safety: Y
- Location: CT, Manchester
Re: Magneto vs. Distributor
Magneto:
Distributor (battery ignition)
Thanks to TM Tractors for the photos
Distributor (battery ignition)
Thanks to TM Tractors for the photos
-
- 10+ Years
- Posts: 47
- Joined: Tue Jun 30, 2009 10:32 am
- Zip Code: 80549
- Location: Wellington, CO
Re: Magneto vs. Distributor
I have a magneto on my Cub and just love it. It took some tuning but it'll generally kick over on the first pass of the hand crank (unless it's in a mood, or it's cold out, or its raining, or sometimes when the day ends in 'Y', but I digress).
My wiring harness was in pretty bad shape when I first got the tractor so crank starting was my only option for a couple of years.
My wiring harness was in pretty bad shape when I first got the tractor so crank starting was my only option for a couple of years.
1951 Farmall Cub - "Cranky"
1947 Farmall H - "Bessie"
1945 Ford 9N - "Danny"
"By endurance we shall conquer", E. H. Shackleton
1947 Farmall H - "Bessie"
1945 Ford 9N - "Danny"
"By endurance we shall conquer", E. H. Shackleton
- Boss Hog
- Cub Pro
- Posts: 10290
- Joined: Mon Oct 24, 2005 8:35 pm
- Zip Code: 23962
- eBay ID: dmb2613
- Circle of Safety: Y
- Location: VA. Randolph
Re: Magneto vs. Distributor
The distributor is much more reliable in my opinion. And cheaper to operate. You would do well with a distributor while converting to 12 volt, which is also more reliable. You will hear many say that 6 volts works just as well as long as you keep it serviced on a regular basis. All my cubs are 12 volt, I have few if any trouble starting them even after that have set for 12 months or more. If you want to keep it original go with the mag and 6 volt, if you are going to use it regularly go with the distributor and 12 volt with an alternator.
Boss
Boss
IN GOD WE TRUST
All others pay cash
Boss Hog
Power corrupts; absolute power corrupts absolutely byJohn Emerich Edward Dalberg
All others pay cash
Boss Hog
Power corrupts; absolute power corrupts absolutely byJohn Emerich Edward Dalberg
- brichter
- Cub Pro
- Posts: 1521
- Joined: Sun Jul 11, 2004 2:23 pm
- Zip Code: 32449
- eBay ID: Kinardhippy
- Skype Name: Billy.Ray.Richter
- Circle of Safety: Y
- Location: FL, Kinard
Re: Magneto vs. Distributor
I second Boss on this one.
If you're gonna dream or steal, do it BIG
The best things in life aren't things.
1951 Cub
1963 Corvair
lots more junk
The best things in life aren't things.
1951 Cub
1963 Corvair
lots more junk
-
- 10+ Years
- Posts: 318
- Joined: Mon Feb 25, 2008 8:16 pm
- Zip Code: 44483
- Circle of Safety: Y
- Location: OH
Re: Magneto vs. Distributor
Stick with the mag & 6 volt. IMO
- DieselDennis
- 10+ Years
- Posts: 185
- Joined: Thu Feb 21, 2013 10:04 pm
- Zip Code: 39042
- eBay ID: ccbil
- Tractors Owned: '48 Cub (Great Granddaddy's)
And some bigger ones..... - Location: Brandon, MS
Re: Magneto vs. Distributor
Thanks for the info guys.
The plan is looking to go to a 12V system with a distributor. It looks like when you add in a core charge, I can get a rebuilt distributor for a little bit more than it would take to have the magneto rebuilt.
I plan to take some time with it tomorrow. Taking a few more electrical items look (bad wiring). Probably end up fixing up the fuel delivery first.
The plan is looking to go to a 12V system with a distributor. It looks like when you add in a core charge, I can get a rebuilt distributor for a little bit more than it would take to have the magneto rebuilt.
I plan to take some time with it tomorrow. Taking a few more electrical items look (bad wiring). Probably end up fixing up the fuel delivery first.
'48 Cub 12V Conversion, Zenith Carb, Electronic Ignition
-
- 10+ Years
- Posts: 318
- Joined: Mon Feb 25, 2008 8:16 pm
- Zip Code: 44483
- Circle of Safety: Y
- Location: OH
Re: Magneto vs. Distributor
Do yourself a favor and save the old stuff.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Dave Downs, Flemmingth and 48 guests