Anything that might not belong on the other message boards!
Moderator: Team Cub
1. Keep it clean.
2. Keep the discussion civil.
3. Name calling is not allowed.
Politics and religion are two topics that tend to degenerate into a violation of one of the three simple rules above.
The mods and the site admin reserve the right to "lock" or "delete" any discussion that in our opinion, is "heading in the wrong direction."
MOST of all, be respectful of your fellow Cubber's opinions. Don't expect to change someones belief system from a simple forum on the internet.
11 posts • Page 1 of 1
I am just throwing this out there to see if any forum members has contacts with any outfits that sell and install woodshop dust collection systems. I have done google searches and have come up with several companies and I received a bid yesterday for over $100,000 to install a system in my shop, 850 cfm. I am in east central IL and would like to stay local but my budget is half of that. This is for my school shop, the system I have is from 1954 and is breaking down. If there is anybody out there that knows of smaller companies please send me a PM and I will contact them. I have contacted all my local HVAC guys around here to and most say it is too commercial for them. I have also contacted the local sheet metal union and have no response from them.
A '54 you say ... geez that is still relatively young .. that's my age
Exactly what is breaking down in your current system At the moment I am currently rebuilding my shop and installing a complete dust extraction system as well as a filter system. Surprisingly much of this stuff can be shop-made and just as good if not better than commercial units as they can be customized to suit your individual shop. This would include particulate management. I have seen a number of quality extraction systems that include cyclones that can be built by any good sheet metal shop. I can go look for that information which may give you some more information for your local sheet metal guys. I can see they being a tad apprehensive but once presented with the sketches etc., I am sure they would say - Hey, I can do that!
A sketch of the shop layout, equipment and of course your current dust collection system would be helpful. To try to recommend something without an idea of what you are up against.
Same question as Rudi asked.
If the duct work is still intact, why not just change out the dust collector? $50K seems high for a new cyclone and perhaps some duct work changes.
Use to teach shop. When the school district had a major project, the head custodian had to submit a bid, his estimate, for the work. This type of project would appear to be well within the capabilities on most school's custodial staff.
I have an excuse. CRS.
We are looking to replace all. The blower fan is is breaking apart and will need rewelded and rebuilt which it has seen twice in the past 20 yrs. All the duct work is breaking down at the welded joints. My head Maint man said it is time for a complete new system. The bid we have is for a CamFill collection system. It is the top of the line system. We are looking to get the blower and all installed and I will most likely install all the duct work this summer and over the course of the school year.
We are pulling off 8 stationary machines and several portables so a simple set up is not going to work.
This is the system I like.
Waiting on a bid from these folks
Now I can see $100K. Considering that you may have to install a sprinkler system to bring the new dust collection system up to OSHA standards.
I have an excuse. CRS.
Our local school districts could never afford those types of systems for the school shops - what few we actually do have. Pretty high end filtration systems. I understand the need for clean air probably better than most now, but man that is expensive.
Good luck on the project Jason, keep us posted and pics of the old and new would be nice as it comes along.
Jason, how large of a school shop do you have and how many and what type of machines are you running. That size setup seems pretty excessive for a school shop, I am assuming this is a high school?
Are the firms that have provided you quotes designing the ductwork layout and sizing also? That can make or break a dust collection system.
I will get some pics later but the shop is pretty good sized. I am running 2 table saws, planer, drum sander and shop saws at one time it seems. I will be adding a shaper and wood lathe here shortly. My problem now is everything is breaking down and falling apart at the welds. So we are pricing a new system installed. My room is roughly 40 by 60 and has a main vein and 3 spurs off the main. My maint man at school is the who suggested we replace it.
I got another quote this week that is much more resonable from Honeyville system of Indiana. It is a Cyclone system.
I'll post some pics of my dust collection system soon, you would be very happy with a two stage cyclone unit, very efficient, I use a single stage 5 HP Delta dual 55 gal bag collector, but since you have numerous machines operating at once you will need the additional CFM's. That also makes a huge difference in determining the diameters of the main trunk and branches.
I am assuming they are quoting using galvanized spiral steel pipe runs? I think mine is 20 gauge and came out of PA, I designed my own system since I have taken courses in it.
My shop is 50 x 75 with a 14 x 20 spray room off to the side, so our main shop size is pretty similar to yours.
I bought a majority of my ductwork here:
Excellent quality and fit, union shop, pricey but worth it.
I believe they will also assist in ductwork design and layout to make sure it is sized properly depending on your needs.
Air hand is on our list if we install the duct work ourselves. As of now now quote includes the drawings and plan so we will or should have something to go by.
11 posts • Page 1 of 1
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests